From what I’ve seen in the press, it seems like the things Elon Musk wants to do with Twitter are worthwhile changes designed to make the platform more of a place where everyone can share their ideas rather than a place focused on who can be kept off the service.
To me, that is a very positive step in the right direction. I don’t believe that any service of the kind that Twitter claims to be should be in the business of cutting people off and denying people the right to be heard. We should allow people to say whatever they want, assuming the result is not illegal. We should then argue about what they say on the merits rather than based on the ability to stop them from saying it. While I still don’t think it’s a good thing for a bunch of rich guys like Musk and Zuckerberg to be making decisions about what counts as a worthwhile speech and who has the opportunity to speak, I like Musk’s approach far better than Zuckerberg. And also much better than the approach of the American left and the government, which both want to see choices made to remove some people from the ability to express themselves in this media.
Still, I think that any organization with this much power over what we get to say where we get to say it should be a publicly-traded organization rather than what Musk wants, which is the ability to control the process as a single individual. This is a significant important distinction between Facebook and Musk’s vision for Twitter.
I also think it is terrible that algorithms decide what kind of information should be provided to people based on what they currently believe, which Facebook does now. There should be a default by which people are given all kinds of information they disagree with. I think that Facebook should have a default that the information you receive is not based on what you currently think and therefore exposes you to all sorts of information. It might be worthwhile to also give people an opportunity to have their info tailored to their own thinking and have this be an option that you could purchase but which would not be the primary way your information was otherwise presented to you.